This summer I set out with Magnet alum Annalise Hafner to try every single Cookout milkshake. There are 40 plus on the menu, adding up to more than $150 I spent on Cookout this summer. Cookout is a fast food spot popular among high schoolers for its cheap eats and late hours. Hopefully this ranking will shake up your decisions on what to try next.

Peach Cobbler came out on top. Not an overwhelming peach flavor, and Nila wafers to add some crunch. A true underdog.

The Watermelon was another surprise.  Fresh chunks of Watermelon were mixed with vanilla ice cream to create a unique crisp flavor.

Banana Berry provided more of a smoothie experience rather than milkshake, but good nonetheless.

All the cheesecakes had a sour taste to them but I may be biased due to my hatred of cheese cake.

Finally, Chocolate Cherry tasted like that last chocolate in the box that everyone refuses to it. Kind of like an old grandma candy.

Although we may have began our path on to type-2 diabetes, Cookout became my second home this summer.

Here’s my total list:

1. Peach Cobbler
2. Mocha
3. Peanut Butter fudge
4. Banana pudding
5. Orange Push-up
6. Oreo Mint
7. Butterfinger
8. M&M
9. Caramel Fudge
10. Watermelon
11. Chocolate Chip Mint
12. Peanut Butter
13. Chocolate Malt
14. Health Toffee
15. Reese’s
16. Banana Berry
17. Blueberry
18. Oreo
19. Snickers
20. Double Chocolate
21. Caramel
22. Peanut Butter Banana
23. Peach
24. Cherry Cobbler
25. Strawberry
26. Vanilla
27. Chocolate
28. Banana Fudge
29. Chocolate Mint
30. Banana
31. Red Cherry
32. Cappuccino
33. Banana Nut
34. Chocolate
35. Banana Pineapple
36. Walnut
37. Pineapple
38. Caramel Cheesecake
39. Chocolate Cheesecake
40. Blueberry Cheesecake
41. Strawberry Cheesecake
42. Cherry Cheesecake
43. Chocolate Cherry